Harden Elkington
People have fallen for some wild lies throughout history — fake discoveries, made-up stories, and full-on hoaxes.
These weren’t small tricks either.
Some fooled entire countries and even shaped science or public opinion.
From giant “fossils” to fake alien landings, they show just how easily belief can beat facts.
The Cardiff Giant: America’s Greatest Archaeological Hoax
The Cardiff Giant is one of the boldest hoaxes in U.S. history — a fake 10-foot “petrified man” dug up on a farm in New York in 1869.
It was the work of George Hull, a cigar dealer who’d gotten into an argument about biblical giants.
Annoyed, he decided to prove how easy it was to fool people.
He had a giant figure carved from gypsum, aged it with acid, and buried it on his cousin’s land.
A year later, workers “found” it while digging a well.
The public went wild.
Some thought it was proof of giants from the Bible. Others called it an ancient statue.
Even scientists couldn’t agree.
People paid to see it. Hull made a fortune before admitting it was all fake.
P.T. Barnum even made a copy to cash in on the buzz.
Why it worked:
- It fit into a debate people were already having (religion vs. science).
- Physical “proof” made it hard to ignore, even if it looked suspicious.
- People wanted to believe. And Barnum knew that — which is why he copied it.
The War of the Worlds Broadcast: When Fiction Became Reality
On October 30, 1938, Orson Welles went on air with a radio version of The War of the Worlds.
It was fiction—but a lot of people didn’t realize that right away.
The show sounded like real news reports: Martians landing in New Jersey, shooting death rays, destroying everything in sight.
Welles didn’t set out to trick anyone.
But people who tuned in late missed the intro and thought the reports were real.
Some panicked. Others just got confused.
Either way, it showed how easy it is for a well-produced story to blur into something people think is true.
Why it mattered:
- It showed how powerful radio (and later TV and the internet) could be.
- It reminded people to question what they hear—especially if it sounds urgent.
- It kicked off Orson Welles’ film career.
- And it helped spark future conversations about media responsibility and misinformation.
The Piltdown Man: Science’s Greatest Fossil Fraud
Between 1908 and 1915, a guy named Charles Dawson said he found pieces of an early human in Piltdown, England.
The bones looked like a mashup—human skull, ape jaw.
People thought it was the missing link.
It fit what British scientists wanted to believe—that human evolution happened in England, not Africa or Asia.
So they ran with it.
For decades, the Piltdown Man showed up in textbooks and shaped research.
Then in 1953, the whole thing fell apart.
New dating tools showed the skull was from a medieval human and the jaw came from an orangutan.
Someone had stained the bones and filed the teeth to make them look legit.
What it taught science:
- Wanting something to be true can cloud your judgment (classic confirmation bias)
- Peer review and cross-checking matter
- It slowed down real discoveries about human evolution—especially ones coming from Africa
- It reminded scientists to be skeptical, even of findings that feel convenient
It wasn’t just a prank—it actually set science back.
The BBC Spaghetti Tree Broadcast: April Fools’ Gone Viral
In 1957, the BBC aired a short April Fools’ segment on “Panorama” that showed a Swiss family picking spaghetti from trees.
It looked legit—slow shots of pasta hanging from branches, a calm voiceover talking about how weather affected the “spaghetti harvest,” and farmers worrying about noodle length.
The joke landed because, at the time, spaghetti was still unfamiliar to a lot of people in Britain.
Some viewers even called in asking how to grow their own spaghetti trees.
Why it worked:
- Most folks didn’t actually know how pasta was made
- The BBC was trusted, so no one expected satire
- The production looked real—quiet, serious, and totally deadpan
It’s still one of the best media pranks ever pulled—not because it fooled people, but because it showed how easy it is to make something absurd sound true if the format looks “official.”
The Moon Hoax: Life on the Lunar Surface
Back in 1835, the New York Sun ran a series claiming a British astronomer had found life on the moon—think forests, pyramids, and bat-people.
It was written by a guy named Richard Adams Locke, who mostly wanted to mock over-the-top science reporting.
But people didn’t catch the joke.
Readers believed it. Even other papers picked it up like it was legit. Sales went up fast. Eventually, Locke admitted he made the whole thing up.
Why it mattered:
- It blurred science and storytelling before “fake news” was a thing
- It showed how people trust info when it looks “scientific”
- It tapped into real curiosity about space
- It also helped sell a ton of papers
It’s an early example of media bending truth for attention—and how easy it is to confuse “credible” with “true” when people want to believe.
The Cottingley Fairies: Photography’s Power to Deceive
Two girls in Yorkshire—Elsie, 16, and her cousin Frances, 9—took some photos in 1917 that looked like they were hanging out with fairies.
They used Elsie’s dad’s camera and posed with paper cutouts held up by hatpins. Simple trick.
But people bought it.
The photos got way more attention than you’d expect—mostly because Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (yeah, the Sherlock Holmes guy) believed they were real.
He published them in The Strand Magazine and used them to push his interest in spiritualism.
Experts looked at the photos and called them “authentic,” which helped the story spread.
It wasn’t until the 1980s that the girls (now elderly women) admitted it was a hoax.
What it shows:
- Even basic photo fakes can fool people when they want to believe
- Big names can give false stories way too much weight
- Early photo “analysis” wasn’t as foolproof as people thought
- This was basically a warm-up for the Photoshop era
It’s a reminder that “seeing” something—especially in a photo—doesn’t mean it’s real.
The Hitler Diaries: Historical Forgery on a Grand Scale
In 1983, Stern magazine dropped millions on what they thought were Hitler’s personal diaries—60 volumes supposedly covering 1932 to 1945.
A few handwriting experts backed them up, and big outlets like Newsweek and The Times were ready to run with it.
The diaries seemed legit at first.
They had juicy personal stuff about Hitler’s life and wartime decisions.
But then forensic tests showed the paper and ink were modern.
The handwriting? Also fake.
The guy behind it, Konrad Kujau, had been faking Hitler memorabilia for years.
He made a fortune off the diaries before getting caught.
The fallout wrecked Stern’s credibility and exposed just how easy it is for hype and money to cloud basic judgment.
Takeaways:
- You need actual forensic testing, not just “expert” opinions
- Money and headlines can override caution, fast
- Real historical verification takes time and multiple checks
- It changed how people vet historical documents today
The Enduring Legacy of Historical Hoaxes
Historical hoaxes show just how easy it is to fool people—then and now.
They worked not because people were dumb, but because the lies fit what folks wanted to believe: religion, science, politics, or mystery.
We still fall for stuff today, just faster and louder.
The trick is knowing that our brains love a good story, even when it’s fake.
So yeah, laughing at old hoaxes is fun—but they’re reminders.
If we don’t slow down and think, we’re just as likely to get played.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings