Why We Love to Judge Others: The Psychology of Moral Superiority

We’ve all done it—judged someone for their actions, beliefs, or lifestyle choices.

It often feels satisfying to see ourselves as “better” or “more right” than others.

But why do we love to judge others?

And what psychological forces drive our sense of moral superiority?

In this blog post, we’ll dive deep into the psychology behind moral superiority, the consequences of harboring this mindset, and practical ways to overcome it.

Let’s explore what makes us tick and how understanding this can improve our relationships and personal growth.

What Is Moral Superiority?

Moral superiority is the belief that your values, principles, or actions are better than someone else’s.

It can make people feel like they’re “in the right” while others are “in the wrong.”

While it’s good to feel confident in your moral beliefs, things can take a negative turn when this mindset leads to judging or criticizing others.

In extreme cases, it can create arrogance, a lack of empathy, or even cause division between people.

Remember, having strong values is important, but it’s equally important to approach others with understanding and respect—even if their perspectives or choices are different from yours.

The Roots of Moral Superiority

To understand why people sometimes feel morally superior, we need to dive into a few key psychological ideas.

These theories help explain the mindset behind this behavior and how it shapes our interactions with others.

Social identity theory

Humans naturally like to group themselves based on things like political beliefs, religion, or cultural background.

This is what psychologists call Social Identity Theory.

In-group vs out-group

We tend to view our own group—the “in-group”—as better, while stereotyping or undervaluing those outside it—the “out-group.”

This can make us feel like we belong and even boost our self-esteem.

Example: 

Imagine someone feels morally superior because their group supports a cause they believe is just.

They may see those who disagree as less ethical or compassionate, even without knowing their full story.

The need for self-esteem

Sometimes, moral superiority is about protecting our own self-worth.

It can act as a defense mechanism when we feel insecure or uncertain.

Downward comparisons

Research shows that people often judge others harshly to feel better about themselves.

By focusing on others’ mistakes or flaws, we subtly boost our own self-esteem.

Example: 

Someone might criticize another person’s diet or parenting style, not because they’re truly concerned, but because they feel unsure about their own choices in those areas.

Moral foundations theory

This theory suggests that our moral judgments are based on six core values: care, fairness, loyalty, authority, sanctity, and liberty.

The tricky part is that different people prioritize these values differently, which can lead to conflict.

Clashing values

If someone prioritizes fairness above all else, they might look down on others who unintentionally act in ways they see as unfair.

Meanwhile, those people might value loyalty or liberty more, creating tension and feelings of superiority.

Example: 

Someone might feel morally superior for standing up for fairness, while judging others who seem to turn a blind eye, even if the situation is more complex than it appears.

The Consequences of Moral Superiority

Feeling morally superior might boost your ego for a moment, but it often comes at a cost to your relationships, personal growth, and even society.

Here’s how it can affect us:

It hurts relationships

When we judge others or act like we’re always “in the right,” it can put a strain on our connections with friends, family, and coworkers.

Constant criticism can make people feel unappreciated or even attacked, leading to tension and resentment.

No one likes to feel like they’re being looked down on.

It fuels political divides

Moral superiority is a major driver of political polarization.

A 2020 study published in Nature Human Behaviour found that when we see those with different political beliefs as morally “less than,” it deepens divisions and makes it harder to have meaningful conversations.

Instead of solving problems together, we end up talking past each other.

It blocks personal growth

Thinking you’re always right leaves little room for self-reflection.

This kind of mindset makes it tough to learn, adapt, or recognize your own flaws.

Growth comes from being open to other perspectives, and moral superiority can close that door.

Overcoming Moral Superiority

It’s natural to feel confident in your beliefs, but it’s just as important to balance that confidence with humility and understanding.

Here are some practical ways to keep moral superiority in check:

Embrace humility

Humility means acknowledging that no one has all the answers—not even you.

• Think about times when you’ve been wrong or changed your perspective.
• Remember, everyone’s views are shaped by their unique life experiences. What you see as “right” might look different to someone else for valid reasons.

Practice empathy

Empathy helps you move from judgment to understanding.

• Ask yourself questions like, “What might they be going through?” or “Why do they see things this way?”
• Truly listen when others speak—don’t interrupt or mentally prepare your counterarguments while they’re talking.

Focus on constructive conversations

Instead of letting disagreements become arguments, approach them as opportunities to learn.

• Use “I” statements to share your perspective without sounding accusatory. For example, “I feel differently about this because…”
• Avoid jumping to conclusions about someone’s intentions or intelligence. Give them the benefit of the doubt and stay open-minded.

By staying humble, empathetic, and open to dialogue, you can connect more deeply with others—even when you don’t agree.

It’s not about lowering your values but understanding that everyone’s journey is different.

Final Thoughts

Judging others might give us a fleeting sense of satisfaction, but it often comes at the cost of our relationships and personal growth.

Understanding the psychology of moral superiority can help us recognize when we’re falling into this trap and choose a path of empathy, humility, and constructive dialogue instead.

The next time you catch yourself feeling morally superior, pause and reflect: Are you building bridges or burning them?

True growth comes from connection, understanding, and a willingness to admit that we’re all human—flaws and all.

FAQs